The Dems' Main Narrative for the Schumer Shutdown Is Falling Apart
CNN's Van Jones Reveals What Schumer Told Him Three Months Ago About Shutting...
AG Bondi to Appeal 'Woefully Insufficient' Sentence for Justice Kavanaugh's Would-be Assas...
No, NYT, We Don't Need to Feel Bad for These People
Scott Wiener: Accusations of Fascism Will Continue Until Conservatives Bend the Knee to...
Colorado Authorities Reopen Investigation Into Death of Hunter S. Thompson
Maxwell House Coffee’s Temporary Rebrand Is Something Else
Hope Amid Chaos in Nigeria
Maryland Accountant Sentenced to 3 Years for $24M COVID Relief Fraud
Over 90,000 Investors Scammed in $200M Bitcoin Fraud
Federal Agents Rammed, Boxed In by 10 Vehicles Near Chicago
Flexing Fraud: Fake Gym at Center of $3M PPP Scam
The Train of Progress Must Not Be Derailed
Trump Ends the Green Scam — Now the Crying Caucus Is Out of...
Make Protecting Animals Great Again: The Trump Administration Is Ending Animal Cruelty
OPINION

Kansas’s March Toward Medicaid For All Is Based on Myths, Not Facts

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.
AP Photo/John Hanna

This week, liberal Gov. Laura Kelly of Kansas announced her plan to bring ObamaCare’s Medicaid expansion to the state, opening up the program to an unlimited number of able-bodied, working-age adults. But state lawmakers should be very skeptical of the alleged benefits of this “Medicaid For All” plan. Specifically, there are five major myths about the proposal that should be rejected, full stop.

Advertisement

Myth #1: Gov. Kelly’s plan is not ObamaCare but rather a “conservative” approach.

In reality, this plan is nothing short of a full ObamaCare expansion plan. If adopted, it would provide full ObamaCare benefits to ObamaCare-eligible able-bodied adults, using ObamaCare dollars, funding with new national debt. Plain and simple, this is a proposal to bring ObamaCare’s reckless expansion to Kansas.

Myth #2: Gov. Kelly’s plan will “promote personal responsibility.” 

Gov. Kelly claims her plan will “promote personal responsibility,” but expanding welfare to able-bodied, childless adults do no such thing. Indeed, it does quite the opposite.

According to a national study by the Foundation for Government Accountability, more than half of ObamaCare expansion enrollees do not work at all.

Why would Kansas expect anything different under this plan? Gov. Kelly would argue it’s because she’s proposing a “work referral” program, under which enrollees will be told, “If you want a job, you can get one!” Just one problem: if enrollees choose to ignore the referrals, they can remain unemployed and keep their benefits, forever. 

Perhaps it’s obvious why this is not a serious attempt to promote personal responsibility.

In case it’s not, consider the experience of Arkansas: this type of “work referral” program was tried and failed, with less than five percent of enrollees taking any action at all on referrals. Kansas should expect similar dismal results.

Advertisement

Myth #3: Gov. Kelly’s plan will save struggling Kansas hospitals. 

States have mistakenly expanded ObamaCare for years in hopes that it would cure what ails their local hospitals. But after years of expansion dollars flowing in, hospitals in expansion states are still struggling. 

In Arkansas, for example, hospitals are still closing. The state’s largest state-run hospital has laid off hundreds of employees. The largest hospital in the state reported more than $50 million of operating losses over two years, after years of ObamaCare expansion.
This was never supposed to happen; we’ve spent billions of dollars on Medicaid for able-bodied adults, trying to ensure it didn’t happen. But it is, and Kansas shouldn’t expand Medicaid based on the same false hope.

And if they do, they may actually worsen the outlook for hospitals in their state by shifting thousands of Kansans from private insurance into Medicaid.

Myth #4: Gov. Kelly’s plan is needed to help the uninsured.

If Kansas expands ObamaCare, they aren’t primarily helping the uninsured—they’re helping able-bodied adults who already have insurance shift the cost of their coverage onto taxpayers. 

Most of the able-bodied adults who would qualify for Medicaid under the ObamaCare expansion in Kansas—54 percent of them, in fact—already have private insuranceAn additional five percent already qualify for virtually free coverage on the ObamaCare exchange.

Advertisement

But by expanding Medicaid, Kansas would shift many of these individuals off of private insurance and onto taxpayer-funded, government-run health care.

Able-bodied adults who are actually uninsured have lots of options to find care or coverage in Kansas, including free charitable clinics, community health clinics, short-term insurance plans, and more. 

But make no mistake: If Kansas expands Medicaid, they are primarily expanding to cover able-bodied adults who already have insurance.

Myth #5: Gov. Kelly’s plan does not require a tax increase.

Gov. Kelly says her plan “does not require a tax increase.” Maybe it’s just semantics because Kansas hospitals are volunteering (as opposed to being required) to chip in tens of millions of dollars to help pay for the program. Regardless, this is tantamount to a tax on every patient in the state of Kansas. 

Why? Because hospitals don’t print money—they get it from patients who come through their doors and from taxpayers who help subsidize them in various ways. Without a doubt, these costs will be passed on to Kansans.

And perhaps more to the point, ObamaCare expansion in Kansas will almost certainly necessitate a tax increase in the very near future. Medicaid already consumes more than 21 percent of the state’s budget and the hospitals’ pledged contributions will cover only a fraction of the annual costs.

Advertisement

Perhaps the biggest myth of all is that ObamaCare’s Medicaid expansion will work. It has failed everywhere else it has been tried. There’s no reason to think, should they proceed down this path, that Kansas’s experience will be any different.

Nic Horton is research director at the Foundation for Government Accountability.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement