Two young women. Two public trains. Two cities controlled by progressive politicians who have turned criminal leniency into theology. Two brutal attacks committed in front of witnesses. Two repeat offenders who should never have been free. And in the end, perhaps the most devastating indictment of all: no one helped. Not until it was too late.
In Chicago, 26-year-old Bethany MaGee, a business research analyst with her whole life ahead of her, boarded a CTA Blue Line train last week. She never made it home. Prosecutors say Lawrence Reed, 50, a man with a criminal history reportedly involving more than 70 prior arrests and more than 50 separate cases, walked up to her, doused her with gasoline, and lit her on fire in the middle of a crowded train car. Passengers watched in horror. Many backed away. Some filmed. What they did not do was stop the attack.
Bethany collapsed, engulfed in flames, receiving help only after she was dragged off the train onto the platform. She is now in critical condition, fighting for her life with burns across more than half her body. Days later in a Chicago courtroom, the man accused of turning her body into a torch shouted again and again: “I plead guilty!” It was not the voice of a remorseful man—it was the chant of someone enjoying the spectacle of his own violence.
Chicago’s leadership had almost nothing to say. Because in a city where the mayor spends more time demonizing police than protecting human beings—and where progressive judges treat violent offenders like misunderstood victims—public safety is no longer a priority. It’s an obstacle.
In Charlotte, 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska was riding the Lynx Blue Line light rail when Decarlos Brown Jr., 34, sat behind her. Without warning, police say he pulled a knife and stabbed her repeatedly: once in the back, once in the head, once in the neck. She bled to death on the floor of the train. She never had a chance to scream. And again—passengers watched. They stepped away. They froze. They filmed. But no one intervened before she collapsed.
Afterward, according to federal affidavits, Brown reportedly walked away bragging something to the effect of “I got that white girl.” A grotesque, celebratory taunt—not from a deranged loner having a breakdown, but from a man who knew exactly what he had done and felt pride in it. He now faces first-degree murder charges and federal terrorism enhancements. But the relevant question remains: why was he free to begin with?
Like Reed in Chicago, Brown had a record of past arrests. Like Reed, he had been processed and re-released. Like Reed, he was walking the streets because prosecutors and judges—driven by political ideology rather than public safety—repeatedly gave violent criminals another chance. And in jurisdictions intoxicated by criminal justice “reform,” both men were treated with more concern than the women they would ultimately destroy.
So which failure is worse? That two violent predators carried out unspeakable crimes? Or that dozens of adults nearby chose silence and self-preservation over courage?
We have become a nation where the innocent are disposable, the violent are protected, bystanders are paralyzed, leaders are asleep, justice is optional, safety is secondary, fear is enforced, and courage is punished. All of it is justified in the name of progressive virtue. Chicago’s leadership is busy attacking police departments and defending criminals through “equity.” Charlotte’s leadership is busy celebrating reforms that now have real names, real faces, and real blood attached to them.
When you prioritize ideology over human life, human life becomes the acceptable cost of your agenda. When violent offenders with dozens of priors roam freely because prosecutors are terrified of appearing “too harsh,” innocents die. When you teach a culture that intervention is dangerous, that masculinity is toxic, that self-defense is racist, and that filming trauma is easier than stopping it, you raise a society too afraid to act. When conviction is replaced with compliance, trains become slaughterhouses.
And here is the hardest question of all: where were the men? On both trains were physically capable adult men who stood still and watched young women be butchered. We once lived in a nation where strangers leapt toward danger—not away from it. Where protecting the vulnerable was instinctive. Where the sight of a woman under attack would trigger immediate action. Now we live in a society taught to fear involvement, avoid conflict, obey silence, and let someone else handle it. Except—there was no someone else.
Bethany MaGee is fighting for her life.
Iryna Zarutska lost hers.
Both were victims of brutality—but also victims of a culture that no longer values courage, responsibility, or the defense of the innocent.
So the question that must haunt every single American is this: What kind of nation have we become if the innocent can be murdered in front of us and we do nothing? And an even harder question follows: What kind of nation will we be the next time evil steps onto a train? Because evil is not afraid anymore. And why should it be? No one stops it. No one confronts it. No one helps.
And unless something changes immediately, the next Bethany or Iryna is already out there, riding her last train, surrounded by witnesses who will watch her die.
America must decide if it will remain passive passengers—or if it will finally stand up, before there is no one left to save.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member