Since 1905, Alberta has periodically debated separation from Canada. Those discussions often focus on energy policy, federal overreach, or fiscal imbalance. The deeper motivation, however, is rooted in long-standing economic and political grievances that have defined Alberta’s place within the federation. When those grievances are combined with an education system that consistently outperforms the rest of the country, the case for autonomy becomes more compelling.
Alberta contributes far more to federal revenues than it receives in return. Between 2007 and 2022, the province paid roughly $244 billion more into federal coffers than it received through transfers—the largest net contribution of any province.
At the same time, federal policies have disproportionately constrained Alberta’s energy-based economy. Oil and gas account for roughly 25–30 percent of Alberta’s GDP and support hundreds of thousands of jobs, yet major projects such as Energy East and Northern Gateway were cancelled amid federal regulatory barriers. These decisions reinforced a perception that Ottawa benefits from Alberta’s prosperity while limiting the very industries that generate it.
Equalization payments further intensify that frustration. The program redistributes federal tax revenue to provinces with lower fiscal capacity, but natural resource revenues are excluded from the formula. In 2023–24, equalization payments totaled more than $23 billion, and Alberta received none of it, despite high living costs, rapid population growth, and significant economic volatility. Many Albertans view this structure as inequitable: the province subsidizes the rest of the country while its own core industries face the most restrictive federal policies.
These grievances shape the political backdrop against which Alberta’s education system stands out. Unlike other regions where public spending grows without structural reform, Alberta has built a model that consistently delivers measurable results. That contrast raises a fundamental question: why should a province capable of designing superior systems remain bound to federal frameworks that underperform?
Recommended
Canada lacks a unified national structure for standardized K–12 academic measurement. Each province administers separate assessments, leaving international testing as the most credible benchmark. On the 2022 Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), Alberta ranked first in Canada in science and reading and second in mathematics. Its average science score of 534 exceeded the Canadian average of 515 and outperformed Ontario and British Columbia across all core subjects. In reading, Alberta’s score of 525 was the highest in the country.
The pattern holds across practical skills. On PISA’s financial literacy assessment, Alberta students averaged approximately 528 points, above both national and OECD averages. Nearly 19 percent reached the highest proficiency level, compared with about 15 percent in Ontario and British Columbia, and only 13 percent scored below baseline proficiency—far lower than the OECD average of 18 percent.
Alberta’s students are not just mastering academic material; they are developing competencies tied to long-term economic independence.
These outcomes are the product of Canada’s most choice-driven K–12 education system. Alberta funds multiple schooling pathways on a per-student basis, including traditional public schools, Catholic public schools, public charter schools, publicly funded private schools, and supported home education. Funding follows the student, fostering competition and rewarding performance.
Alberta is the only province that not only permits but actively encourages public charter schools—tuition-free, independently operated institutions with mission-specific models ranging from classical education to STEM. Demand exceeds supply each year, and waitlists persist across the province. Private schools also receive approximately 70 percent of their funding from public sources, creating diverse options without forcing families to shoulder the full cost of tuition.
School choice is codified in Alberta’s Education Act, establishing a legally recognized marketplace rather than a single delivery model.
Alberta’s achievements are even more notable given its demographic diversity, including rural communities, Indigenous students, and large immigrant populations. The province also reports one of the highest average IQ scores in Canada—approximately 101.5 compared with a national average of 99—but policy design, not cognitive potential alone, drives outcomes. Alberta has built systems that convert ability into results.
Combined with a sustained economic boom and a fundamentally stronger education system, Alberta’s population growth now far outpaces every other region in Canada. While Alberta’s birth rate sits modestly above the national average, the primary driver is strong net interprovincial migration.
In 2022 and 2023 alone, Alberta gained more than 50,000 residents per year from other provinces, the largest net inflow in the country. Most newcomers arrived from Ontario, British Columbia, and Atlantic Canada—regions with higher housing costs, slower wage growth, and fewer economic opportunities. Population movement at this scale signals revealed preference: Canadians are voting with their feet, and Alberta is the destination.
When a province consistently outperforms national averages, contributes disproportionately to federal revenues, and maintains world-class education through decentralization and parental choice, it naturally questions its place in a federation that restricts its core industries and redistributes its wealth.
Alberta’s economic and educational outcomes strengthen the intellectual case for autonomy. A province that has demonstrated success through competition, accountability, and institutional design has little incentive to subordinate that model to national frameworks that have failed to match it. In both policy and performance, Alberta has shown what works. The rest of Canada has chosen not to follow.
Editor’s Note: Do you enjoy Townhall’s conservative reporting that takes on the radical left and woke media? Support our work so that we can continue to bring you the truth.
Join Townhall VIP and use promo code FIGHT to receive 60% off your membership.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member