We tried to warn you, Colts Nation. Daniel Jones is fool’s gold. The Indianapolis Colts gave Jones a two-year, $88 million extension. Keep in mind, this team started 8-2 last season. They were calling him Indiana Jones. He was not. The Colts missed the playoffs in an epic collapse. And before you say, ‘Well, Jones tore his Achilles,’ which he did in week 14, the train was already coming off the rails. Now, they’re in the AFC South basement at 3-7, where Colts fans are starting to learn what Jones does well.
And that is killing franchises and costing games. The number of general managers and coaches who have lost their jobs betting on him is innumerable. He’s not good. He’s not a franchise quarterback, and you can’t build around him. I suffered through watching this clown for six years as a New York Giants fan. We tried. We protected the blindside with Andrew Thomas. We got him an elite wide receiver in Malik Nabers. It all gets canceled out because Daniel Jones is not good, but his sports agent is exceptional, robbing what seems like the GDP of Brazil from two franchises. Was he going to do better? Sure, I would’ve said that given that the AFC South is weaker competition. He’s playing the worst ball of his life, with a QBR rating of 1.7 last Sunday against the lowly Miami Dolphins, who nearly won. Indy’s defense bailed out Jones. His passer rating was 41.5, as he couldn’t manage to throw for 110 yards.
“I got to play better” is a repetitive and frankly annoying quote from Jones every time he gets wrecked. It’s not going to happen, because you’re not good, Jones. Maybe a step or two above Dave Brown, another Duke quarterback the Giants took who was also a miserable experiment.
Worse, Colts head coach Shane Steichen refuses to bench him. Then again, it’s not like Indy has better long-term options in the wings. Still, the Baghdad Bob answers from Steichen are leading beat writers to lose patience, as they know the butcher’s bill. Also, the leash that Jones is on is noticeable, as it seems to stretch the length of the Mississippi River, whereas other players were not so fortunate (via The Athletic):
Entering Sunday night, Jones leads the NFL with 15 turnovers (12 interceptions and three lost fumbles), and he’s tied for the league high in picks. His 12 interceptions are also tied for the most he’s had in his career despite there still being seven games left in this season.
Steichen said Jones would remain the Colts’ starting QB this week since they have a quick turnaround and will face the Houston Texans on the road Thursday. However, the question of whether Jones should be benched for Anthony Richardson Sr. (or heck, even 2025 sixth-round pick Riley Leonard), isn’t just about one game or one week. It’s about a coach always finding a way to defend a player whose play has been indefensible.
That routine continued Sunday when Steichen was asked how much more the team needs from Jones.
[…]
He continues to suffer from poor decision-making, and while he keeps apologizing for it, it doesn’t improve.
[…]
Case in point: the pick six. Facing first-and-10 from Miami’s 48-yard line, Jones dropped back to pass and surveyed the field as the Dolphins’ pass rush slowly closed in. As Jones bought time with his legs and escaped the pocket, he could’ve simply thrown the ball out of bounds when he realized no one was open. Instead, with Indy ahead 21-10, he chucked an errant pass toward tight end Drew Ogletree, who dove to try to make the catch, only for the ball to bounce off his hands and into Johnson’s.
“Obviously, (he) tried to make a play,” Steichen said, deflecting again. “Went off of Ogletree’s hands right there in that situation, and obviously went the other way.”
Steichen couldn’t concede that Jones simply made a terrible choice and threw a terrible pass. Instead, he continued to defend Jones, sounding more like Jones’ attorney than his coach.
No other player throughout Steichen’s tenure in Indianapolis has ever received this long of a leash without the performance to back it up. When wide receiver AD Mitchell infamously dropped the ball at the goal line in a loss against the Los Angeles Rams last year, which negated a would-be touchdown, he was benched until he was traded. When Richardson tapped out of a loss at Houston in 2024 because he was tired, he was benched the following week due to what Steichen cited as a lack of professionalism.
Every week, there will be questions about him getting benched. It will stop once he plays better. And we all know he won’t. As Giants fans, we saw this, endured it, and thankfully are moving on.
Why are we hard on the kid? Because annoying Giants fans still think there’s something special about this kid. He sucks. And a lot decided to root for the Colts last year after their 8-2 start, saying, ‘Look, see, I told you he’s good or a franchise guy.’
Nope. He sucks. The tape doesn’t lie. He’s a franchise killer. He’s a backup, a total bust. And he’ll likely cost Steichen his job.
Colts beat tanking Dolphins in spite of QB Daniel Jones. Why won't Shane Steichen play QB2 Anthony Richardson? I asked Steichen. Then I asked Richardson. Then I watched in the locker room as two Colts QB's ignored the third one. Guess who was ignored? https://t.co/KRD76RlNsz
— GreggDoyelStar (@GreggDoyelStar) November 16, 2026