Sorry, Jessica, WE DID VOTE FOR THIS
Supreme Court Hands Trump White House a Major Win, and Slaps Down Justice...
Stephanopoulos Is Under Water With Flood Accusations, and 25 years Is Too Little...
Stealth Bombers and Bunker Busters for Israel?
Philly Drowns in Trash As Union, Mayor Face Off
Karoline Leavitt Delivers Perfect Response to Reporter’s Stupid Question on Texas Flood Al...
Former Mamdani Intern Berates Muslim NYPD Officer at Pro-Palestinian Protest in Resurfaced...
JD Vance Goes Scorched Earth on NYC Muslim Socialist Candidate
FBI Launches Criminal Probe Into Brennan, Comey Over Trump-Russia Misconduct
IRS Announces Churches Can Endorse Political Candidates
TSA Announces Major Airport Change
SCOTUS Greenlights Trump’s 'Wrecking Ball' Federal Job Cuts to Move Forward Amid Ongoing...
Any Palestinian State Is a Way to Destroy Israel, Says Netanyahu
Colombia’s Leftist President Shrinks to Trump with Private Apology After Bizarre Coup Accu...
There’s Been a Disturbing Update Surrounding Laken Riley’s Murderer
OPINION

Elizabeth Warren's Upside Down Argument

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.

Elizabeth Warren, liberal candidate for the senate in Massachusetts, recently declared that nobody succeeds on their own in the country. This is true. There are always many people involved in any success. But she took it one step further, stating that success is a gift from civilized society:

Advertisement

 

There is nobody in this country that got rich on their own – nobody. You built a factory out there; good for you. I want to be clear: You moved your goods to market on roads the rest of us paid for. You hired workers the rest of us paid to educate. You were safe in your factory because of police forces and fire forces that the rest of us paid for. You didn’t have to worry that marauding bands would come and seize everything at your factory and hire someone to protect against this – because of the work the rest of us did.

 

 

I’m an entrepreneur who started Heart of America Group with a little 100-seat restaurant in 1978 which has grown to over 30 hotels and properties; I thought I would educate Professor Warren a little bit.

 

One of my businesses is a 137-room hotel with a restaurant and banquet facilities. Last year this hotel paid quite a bit for roads, fire and police, and schools. Property taxes were $410,695, “pillow” taxes were $240,497 and sales and use taxes were $329,962. That’s almost $1 million before I pay the people that work at the hotel, the utilities, the payroll taxes at $183,232, or a nickel to the bank on their annual mortgage payment of $1,028,892 a year for twenty years. That $1 million of local taxes is before I pay any state or federal income taxes and multiple fees.

Doesn’t that sound like a “fair share” for a single, relatively small hotel?

Advertisement

In fact, Professor Warren’s argument is exactly upside down. My little hotel doesn’t drive on the roads, use the library or send kids to public schools. How do you think these things are paid for, by the household that pays $4,500 a year in property taxes and sends 2 kids to school at $12,000 per year?

Professor Warren refers to “the rest of us” as an equal partner in all our endeavors and the government as the way “the rest of us” gets our “fair share.” But “the rest of us” were not the ones that worked the 16-hour days, seven days a week that my wife and I did when we first started Heart of America Group. “The rest of us” were not the ones who had to give personal guarantees for bank loans that put everything we had at risk. Forgive me, but it appears to me that “the rest of us” are entitled to a lot, but did not put in any work or any risk.

Professor Warren turns America’s need for limited government, so not to live in the state of nature, into an argument that society at large has a claim on all the fruits of our labors. John Locke must be turning in his grave.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement