And With That Development, the GOP Should Fire the Dem Senate Parliamentarian
Here's What the Trump Administration Plans to Do Once Kilmar Abrego Garcia Is...
They Strip-Searched, Shackled, and Detained This Grandmother – They Had the Wrong Suspect
Top Putin Ally Backs Off Claim That Russia Could Supply Iran With Nukes...
CNN Is in Complete Defense Mode After Being Called Out for Errant Reporting...
Precision Over Panic: Never Underestimate American Lethality
Another Company Chooses to Invest Stateside
China Plays Dirty in Rare-Earth Magnet Trade
Mayor Eric Adams Officially Launches Bid for Reelection As an Independent
Axios Mocked for Coverage on Trump Administration's Plans to Deport Abrego Garcia Once...
Radical Leftist Congressman Doubles Down on Profanity-Laced Insults Against Stephen Miller
New Poll Gives Swing State Governor Some Bad News
Unmasked: Former High-Ranking NYS Employee Indicted for COVID-19 PPE Fraud
'This Is Bulls**t': NSF Employees Protest HUD Relocation
Homan Won’t Let Far-Leftist Running for NYC Mayor Keep ICE Away
OPINION

Texas 2014 Abortion Data Provides Little Evidence of a Public Health Crisis

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.

Last week, NBCNews.com posted a story arguing that Texas’s pro-life law HB2 caused a significant increase in second-trimester abortions in Texas.  Between 2013 and 2014, the number of second- trimester abortions in Texas increased by about 27 percent. The author argues that in the aftermath of HB2, which strengthened health standards for Texas abortion facilities, clinics closed and travel distances for women seeking abortions increased.  As such, more Texas women were obtaining abortions later in pregnancy – when they are more expensive and when abortion poses greater health risks.  This increase in second-trimester abortions has been reported by a number of other media outlets including Cosmopolitan and the Austin American-Statesman.

Advertisement

However, a closer look at the 2014 abortion data provides little evidence of a public health crisis in Texas.  Additionally, some of the abortion data released by the Texas Department of State Health Services indicates that HB2 may have actually improved public health in some respects.  For instance, the 2014 abortion data indicates that the number of abortions performed in Texas fell by 14 percent between 2013 and 2014. However, the incidence of abortion fell by 21 percent for Texas teenagers and by over 23 percent for Texas minors.  Good research indicates that abortions performed on minor girls pose greater health risks than abortions performed on adult women – so by this measure HB2 might have actually improved public health.

Second, it is true that data from the Texas Department of State Health Services indicates that second-trimester abortions increased the year after HB2 took effect. However, as someone who has conducted academic research on abortion trends, I am wary about drawing conclusions from one year’s worth of abortion data.  Furthermore, the 6,117 second-trimester abortions that were performed in Texas in 2014 are not a particularly high number for the state by historical standards. As recently as 2008, over 6,000 second-trimester abortions were performed in Texas. Furthermore, in 2005, 2006, and 2007 there were more second-trimester abortions in Texas than there were in 2014. During those years, the mainstream media were certainly not sounding complaints about a public health crisis.

Advertisement

Since 2011, Texas has taken the lead at enacting protective pro-life legislation. The state has excluded Planned Parenthood from the state women’s health care program, banned abortions after 20 weeks, and attempted to improve regulation of abortion facilities.  Unsurprisingly, the mainstream media have worked overtime to find evidence of a public health crisis.  However, data from the Texas Department of State Health Services shows that abortions have continued their long-term decline and the state fertility rate has actually fallen.  Furthermore, there is no evidence of an increase in unintended pregnancies.

As such, many on the left hoped the 2014 abortion data would give them evidence they needed. In fact, the ACLU even threatened legal action, claiming the Texas Department of State Health Services was withholding the data until the Supreme Court could issue its decision in Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt.  This was ironic considering the ACLU has not once criticized the CDC or any other state health department for failing to report abortion data in a timely manner.  However, the pattern is the same.  Plenty of media noise, but little evidence that pro-life policies are actually hurting the health of Texas women.

Advertisement

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement