Obama Might Not Have the Legal Protections Libs Thinks He Has Regarding the...
CNN's Top Legal Analyst Just Blew Apart the Dems' Anti-Trump Narrative on Federalizing...
The Dems' 'Crime in D.C. Is Down' Narrative Just Got Taken to the...
The Daily Beast Just Got a Brutal Fact-Check...and It's Absolutely Insane
This Blue City Mayor Just Gave a Ridiculous Suggestion on How Trump Can...
Melania Trump Just Declared Open Season on America’s Most Overrated Deadbeat
Gmail Caught Burying GOP Fundraising Emails
Hunter Biden Responds to $1 Billion Legal Threat From Melania Trump
Man Who Hurled a Hoagie at Federal Officer Charged With Felony Assault
Acclaimed NYC Restaurant That Went Entirely Plant-Based Issues Update That Has Enraged Veg...
End Biden’s Big Labor Giveaway Before the Rail Merger Rolls
Abortion and Gender Confusion: A Tale of Two Woke Virginia Schools
With a Side Order of Truth
Trump Sees Himself as DC's Top Lawman
Making American Children Healthy Again
OPINION

What Filibuster ‘Reform’ Is Really About

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of Townhall.com.

As the current Congress wraps up, and in the after-glo of the election, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) is proposing to limit the ability of senators to filibuster in the next Congress. Of course, we’ve heard the arguments about Republican “obstructionism” and not allowing measures to come to a vote. Having spent seven years as Senate staff, this is all spin. Reid’s attempt to ”reform” the filibuster is about one thing:  limiting the ability of Republicans of offer amendments that Reid doesn’t want Democrats to have to vote on.

Advertisement

First, let’s remember that the objective of every majority leader is to stay majority leader. To do so means members of his party must win re-election. One of the important ways a majority leader can facilitate such is to protect his members from tough votes. For instance, witness Reid’s current attempts to stop a vote on Rand Paul’s (R-KY) amendment to limit indefinite detention. You’d think that since many liberal voters and groups oppose indefinite detention, Reid would welcome such a vote. But such a vote would put Democrats and President Obama at odds. So Reid’s favored course of action is to avoid such a vote.

How does this relate to the filibuster? Well after cloture is invoked (see Senate Rule XXII), the only amendments that can be voted on are those that are both pending and germane. And an amendment only gets pending if there’s no objection. All Reid needs to do is oppose amendments for 30 hours, then the curtain comes down and he can force a vote, and this assumes he hasn’t already filled the amendment tree (I’ve witnessed such a process too many times to count). So when Majority Whip Dick Durbin (D-IL) claims, “[w]e’ve had over 300 filibusters in the last six years,” he fails to mention that few of these were actual filibusters. The vast majority were attempts by the Majority to limit amendments by pre-emptively filing cloture.

I’m an empirical person. So while I haven’t found a perfect way to measure this, a good proxy is the ratio of roll call votes to measures passed. After all, a voice vote isn’t much use in forcing uncomfortable votes. Since 1992, the annual average of roll call votes to measures passed is 67 percent. Under Reid its fallen to 60 percent. A good check on whether this a useful indicator is that in election years the measure has been 50 percent, but in non-election years 84 percent, which is what one would expect if a majority leader is trying to protect his members from tough votes.

Advertisement

So don’t be fooled. Reid’s efforts at filibuster reform is not to have more votes, but to have fewer, and to have those votes only on the things which Reid wants voted on. What the Senate really needs is more debate, deliberation, and recorded voting, not less.

This work by Cato Institute is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

Join the conversation as a VIP Member

Recommended

Trending on Townhall Videos

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement